The Wall Street Journal chats with Steve Smith about Students and Finances


image
Here’s something to consider adding to your college student’s list of back-to-school supplies: a stack of envelopes.No, not for sending you snail mail. Rather, for learning how to become financially independent.
True financial independence requires living within your means. And that requires learning how to manage your day-to-day cash flow.

The vast majority of investors practice what Steve Smith, chief executive officer of online budgeting-system developer Finicity™, calls “account balance spending.” That is, they make their routine spending decisions based on the overall balance in their primary account, typically a checking account.

This works pretty well until you have an “emergency,” such as the car breaking down or a long-forgotten insurance payment coming due. Mr. Smith says 20% of our annual spending falls in the category of periodic spending—things like vacations, holiday gifts and those dreaded car repairs.

If you are spending all your cash flow on recurring expenses, such as food and clothing, and not leaving any margin for periodic ones, such as car repairs, you will be forced into the world of “fire hose management,” says Mr. Smith, wherein you pull out the credit card and get the car fixed—because you need it to get to school or work, right?—potentially setting off a cascade of interest charges, late fees and overdraft fees, not to mention a fair amount of stress.

What if, instead, you set aside separate pools of money in advance—OK, maybe not in actual envelopes, but in virtual ones—for all your expenses, the monthly kind (home mortgage) and the periodic (holiday gifts)?

This might be a daunting task for those with complex financial lives. But for a college student it’s relatively easy, and a nice way to build basic money skills and lay the foundation for a lifetime of healthy spending habits.

“If you can get your child to start thinking in terms of envelope balances rather than account balances before they go off to school, you have done them a huge service,” says Mr. Smith, who has four children, including one entering college this year.

Begin by helping your child identify all of his or her school costs (tuition, room and board, books) and living expenses (car insurance, gas, parking). Don’t forget discretionary items like restaurant tabs and concert tickets. For the annual expenses, divide by 12.

Then take your child’s income from all sources—including part-time or summer jobs, scholarships, loans and, of course, the Bank of Mom and Dad—and allocate it among the various envelopes.

Finicity’s www.mvelopes.com helps automate the process by connecting with your existing bank account or accounts, tracking your deposit and spending transactions, and assigning them to various categories, or “envelopes;” the free version handles up to four online accounts and provides for a maximum of 25 envelopes, plenty for someone going off to school.

You also can do a rudimentary version of this through Internet banks such as ING Direct and even traditional banks such as J.P. Morgan Chase, which give you the ability to set up and manage multiple subaccounts online.

Scrutinize each expense, especially the discretionary ones. Sometimes the hardest thing for students to learn is how to say no to spending, especially when all their friends seem to be saying yes.

What you’re trying to do is right-size their month-to-month expenses and build a cushion to absorb the periodic ones.

With that in mind, don’t forget to include an envelope for longer-term savings, such as for a spring-break vacation or a new car.

“The best way to curb your spending is by setting a financial goal worth saving for,” says Bob Stammers, director of investor education at the Chartered Financial Analyst Institute.

Envelope-balance spending is hard-core. If the dining-out envelope runs dry before the month is over, your student will be forced to make a choice: Steal from another envelope (bad choice) or forgo dining out until next month (good choice).

A word about credit cards: Some advisers feel college students should not have credit cards to fall back on. Others feel credit cards, used responsibly (i.e. paid on time and in full), are helpful in building a student’s credit history.

San Diego financial adviser Deborah Fox had her son get a few credit cards when he was in college. He graduated last spring with a credit score of 760, which enabled him to finance the purchase of his first car with an interest rate of 2%.

Of course, Ms. Fox also had her son earn $3,000 to $4,000 per year to cover the bills—”not to be mean,” she says, “but for him to learn how to live within his means.”

It’s a lesson well worth learning, but one not likely to be found between the covers of those pricey college textbooks.

Kiplinger chooses Mvelopes® as “Best for Over-spenders”

As the economy continues to sputter — along with the balance sheets of many families — the Internet has supplied an abundance of online tools to help repair the damage. We’ve scoured the offerings and chosen our favorites for a variety of money-management styles.

Each site offers its own brand of budgeting tool and tracks your cash flow by collecting your financial information in one place, providing access to your complete financial picture anywhere you have Internet access.
To maximize their benefits, most require that you link them to your financial accounts by providing your online user names and passwords. This sharing might sound risky, but none of our favorite tools has experienced security problems. BudgetPulse.com does not ask you to supply your private data. The rest of our picks guard your information from hackers with bank-level security; they encrypt your user names and passwords, meaning they cannot be viewed anywhere in plain text without a key. Even if your account were hijacked, intruders would not be able to execute any money moves because the sites access your financial accounts on a read-only basis.

No matter what your personal finance style, one of these online money-management tools will help you stay in control.

Mvelopes®: Best for Over-Spenders

slideshow imageOne classic budgeting strategy involves physically divvying up your cash and labeling each envelope with a spending category. Once an envelope is empty, that’s it — no more money to put toward that purpose.

Mvelopes digitizes this approach to money management with great success. The site’s average user is able to cut spending by 10%, says chief executive Steve Smith. “You really start managing your finances instead of just reacting to things that happen on a monthly basis.”

With the free membership, you can link up to four financial accounts. If you’re hesitant to share your information, you can opt not to store it, but then you’ll be required to enter it every time you return to the site. Next, you create a spending plan and fund up to 25 envelopes. For $10 a month, a premier subscription allows you an unlimited number of financial accounts and envelopes. Plus, you get access to the site’s debt center and an in-house financial coach, who can advise you on basic money topics and how to use Mvelopes. Using the tool isn’t always intuitive; to get started, we recommend watching the site’s tutorials.